Stalking The Lost Polka : Rotondi
Somewhere in a New York dollar store back in the late 90s, we found a dusty cassette tape. The band was called Rotondi.
When we later all gathered around the cassette player in the family’s recreation room, we were bathed in a weird mix of happy, excited, catchy… polka. And we loved it.
Now, technically, this was ‘New Wave Polka’, a tiny little music scene that seems to have existed for about 30 minutes in a small part of California during the mid-1990s (though some polka-ologists credit the Brave Combo with launching the underpopulated movement in the late 70s). So, we weren’t nearly as dorky as the ‘polka’ label would imply. ‘New Wave Polka’ incorporates all of the accordions, but jazzes up the oom-pah beats and infuses it all with a little bit of rock, pushes it towards zydeco, and takes on the flavor of everything it touches. And kid in upstate NY wasn’t aware of any of this back before the internet did stuff. We had Simon and Garfunkel.
Between my mother and myself, we pretty much wore the tape out, though it still flutters along to this day. It wasn’t until years later that we actually encountered Rotondi’s ‘Preaching and Confessing’ on CD at a different dollar store. Sadly, these two releases seemed to be the only things that Rotondi recorded.
So, I wrote a letter (on actual paper) to their record label to see if there was any more music to be had, and it was actually answered by a band member. For five dollars (to cover shipping), he offered to make me a cassette of some unreleased Rotondi music – and I didn’t follow through, marking one of my biggest music collecting regrets. Back then, I didn’t understand the rarity of a band member actually offering to share their process with you, pre-polish. I want to kick that kid in the pants region.
Rotondi’s response to my initial letter mentioned an even earlier album than the one I’d obtained, though the local Camelot music was useless at helping me find it, and it’s long been out of print. ‘Polka Changed My Life Today’ is actually comprised of a material that would later be released (sometimes after being re-recorded) on future albums, as well as a few songs that remain buried in history. It was only recently that digital music juggernaut iTunes has made these available for download, and the rest of the internet seems to have followed suit. It’s just as the ancient prophets foretold : “Patience is a virtue when hunting for New Wave Polka albums.” Or something like that.
Sure, it’s a discography that spans three whole albums, but it finally feels like a very old collection has finally been completed. In order to completely round out the collection, it became essential to track town an album or two by the Loose Acoustic Trio. This band includes members from Rotondi, and even includes a few re-recordings of great Rotondi songs – in a bluegrass style, which is perhaps the most unexpected departure from polka that one can conceptualize.
It’s because of finding Rotondi in a dollar store bin that I realized that there was amazing, very hidden music in every possible nook and cranny out there, and where you find it should have no bearing on your appreciation of it.

While their catalogue of classics is not available through iTunes or Amazon as MP3s (though the questionable world of
Rush’s first album, simply titled ‘Rush‘ seems to have had at least three versions. The initial pressing of 3500 copies features a cream-colored label and a blue ‘Moon Records’ logo. The second pressing includes a red logo, as opposed to the later pink lettering, as well as a small logo for Moon Records which is missing from later pressings. The pressing of 5000 ‘red’ copies reach prices around $80, opened. Reprints of the ‘pink’ LP sell fairly consistently around the $10 mark. Mine, of course, is the latter.
I’ve also come across at least three versions of 1978’s Hemispheres. While the plain, black vinyl copy sells for only a few bucks, an alternate pressing on red vinyl sells for between $15 and $25. A picturedisc featuring the cover artwork sells for a similar price.




