Our Blog

In Case You Didn’t Check: Fraternal & Convention Badges

11.13.09 By The Dean
Pin Back Badge Collection

Click on any picture to enlarge

Common ConfigurationMost have a common appearance and style, a Cartouche at the top made of thin stamped brass, with an opening to install a printed paper name tag, and two safety type pins on back, one to attach to your clothing and the other to hold a ribbon. The most common ribbon is two colors, black with silver or white lettering on one side and red, blue or white on the another side with bold coloring that will show off the lettering.

Hanging EmblemOften the badge will contain a third element with the organization’s emblem, name or logo. Additional attachments sometimes show up for the wearer’s position (Chairman, Adviser, Treasurer, Greater Than Thou) or years of attendance. Naturally, I search for the oldest badges, and condition is also considered. Convention badges are usually dated and name the city holding the activity, adding instantly to the knowledge the badge presents.

Bastian Bros. SignedSeveral that have passed through my hands have just the initials of the organization or fraternal group. Some are easy to recognize, BPOE (Elks), three intertwined rings (Odd Fellows), etc. With the help of my friends Google and Ask, I have been successful in determining the origins of all the badges I’ve had. Once, while in the process of buying a badge at an antique store in Illinois, the clerk offered to call the dealer that owned it and she was able to provide me with the woman’s organization the emblem on the ribbon represented. It was a fraternal insurance group from Chicago circa 1880s. Another woman’s branch of a male fraternal group had woman’s hands clasped in a handshake. An Odd Fellows badge features two hands in a fist bump.

Back Tells Us MoreBut the face of the badge tells only part of the story. The backs on many have the maker’s mark or name. After quite some time collecting these badges, one starts to guess who the maker might be, before turning them over. When no signature is present, design and quality point to one or another of the various companies producing them over the last century. On the top of my favorites list Bros. John is Whitehead & Hoag in New Jersey from 1892 to 1921. Bastian Bros. of Rochester, New York, did similar work. In the St. Paul – Minneapolis area National Novelty and Brown & Bigelow are seen on some articles. From Milwaukee, Schwaab, a company with 150 years of history, also shows up on badges, and yet another is signed F. W. Fairbairn, Cleveland, O. These names, the styling and the type of holding pin on back, all add up to help determine a ribbon’s age when no date is given directly on the piece.

If your collections include this type of badge, share with all of us through a reply or add your collection to C. Q. for all to see.

---

Article Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

================

Gotta Collect? Then You Gotta Connect - Join our Collectors’ Community!

2 Responses to “In Case You Didn’t Check: Fraternal & Convention Badges”

  1. C. Wood Says:

    Hi I enjoyed your article. I have just been sorting through my dads collection of mostly Elks 1909 Convention badges. I am doing some research before I list on Ebay. THey have been packed away for ever. Any thoughts.
    Thanks

  2. The Dean Says:

    Hello,
    Sounds like a great collection. If your not tied to them for sentimental reasons and no one in the family has an interest in them, then selling the collection is your answer. In selling the badges, I would check the back of the top piece, often the makers mark is there. Several manufacturers are collected, without regard to the organization the badge came from.
    Whitehead & Hoag & Bastian Bros. both from the east coast worked in that era and there were companies in Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul that also made badges that I see from Midwestern conventions.
    Depending on the your E-bay experience, you may already know to list the maker and any location listed on the front or back of the badges, as I have several collectors watching my listings on E-bay and Icollect247, just for their hometown names.
    Happy Collecting,
    dean-ferber@sbcglobal.net

Leave a Reply